Who here doesn’t love a good avocado? They’re nutritious and perfect for instagram but I hate to break this to you, they can’t cure cancer.
There are many great things on Instagram. Puppies, Memes. Bloggers posting great shots and stories. I often see a lot of avocado toast. I also see a lot of health related nonsense.
#healthblogger is a pretty popular hashtag on Instagram, with over 260,000 posts. I like to keep up with my fellow health bloggers, so I check posts with this hashtag. One day, I saw one that hailed the supposed cancer fighting properties of avocados. I was so dumbfounded by it, I took a quick screenshot:
Is there any truth in this?
Well, let’s dissect the post and go through it, bit by bit.
Acute myeloid leukaemia (AML)
First of all, they’re right in saying that AML is the most common acute leukaemia in adults, although, it is actually still a rare form of cancer. Survival rates are incredibly low (10% of living 2 years after diagnosis). What’s more, it’s aggressive and requires chemotherapy, and patients may even need radiotherapy and a bone marrow transplant to be completely cured.1
Now, let’s make this clear, chemotherapy can be carcinogenic. Is this really a major revelation?
Chemotherapy is a nasty treatment, pure and simple. My immunology professor at university would literally tell his patients that he was going to take them to the brink of death and them pull them back in order to treat them.
Some chemotherapy treatments, like alkylating agents, can interfere with DNA.2 This is risky, because cancer is the result of damaged DNA. Internal safety mechanisms that are supposed to stop faulty cells from multiplying fail, and tumours grow.3
I’d like to make it clear that this risk is only associated with SOME chemotherapy treatments, not all.
This Instagram post makes it sound like we’ve uncovered a huge, Big Pharma conspiracy. This isn’t true. The risks are known but, for now, chemotherapy is still one of the best treatments that we have.
Cancer curing properties
First things first, these results have only been seen in vitro, which is in lab-based cell cultures. That being said, this is still promising.
I say this because a lot of pharmaceutical drugs start out as plants. Digoxin, a heart medication, is derived from foxgloves.4 Morphine comes from poppies. So it’s not unheard of plants being used in modern medicine.
Now, let’s talk about avocados and this study. 800 different compounds were tested on lab-grown AML cells. The compound that they isolated from avocados was called avocatin B. Of these 800 compounds, avocatin B was the most effective at causing apoptosis, which is a safe, programmed form of cell death. It also lead healthy, non-cancerous cells unharmed.5
The researchers suggest reason that avocatin B is able to target AML cells so well is because of the cells mitochondria.5 Now, as we all know, the mitochondria is the power house of the cell. It’s where we create our energy, and AML cells have an altered mitochondrial density as well as a greater energy producing capacity. It seems that avocatin B is able to disrupt these altered mitochondria, which leads to the death of AML cells.
So…an avocado a day keeps the cancer at bay. Right?
This is a story that has been reported in the news, as well as on Instagram. Sadly, it’s been misreported. A lot.
Most of these stories make it sound like a daily serving of avocado is going to prevent cancer. This really isn’t the case. One day, science may prove this statement wrong. But for now, there just isn’t any credible evidence.
This is because of one very simple fact. Avocatin B doesn’t come from the edible flesh. It’s only found in the seed. It’s also a compound that has been refined and purified, so I doubt that chomping on the seed is going to help you in any way.
Why this story is such a problem?
Cancer sucks. It can wreck your body and it can kill you. So it’s only natural that we want to root for a cure, from anywhere. We cling onto that hope. We sign up for experimental treatments that sometimes have horrendous side effects. We try natural, raw juice diets. We even have parents kidnapping their children from hospitals in order to try and save them.
This means that when we see a headline that screams ‘X CURES CANCER’ – we’re willing to accept it at face value. We want it to be true. Just look at the case of Belle Gibson. She claimed to have halted cancer in her brain, liver, blood, uterus and spleen with a natural diet. She sold a successful cookbook, The Whole Pantry, and her app was going to be featured on the then new Apple Watch.6
People believed her for two reasons. Firstly, nobody would ever doubt that someone would claim to be so ill. Secondly, as I’ve read in The Woman Who Fooled The World, people wanted to believe her because they wanted to believe in hope. They wanted to believe that this seemingly natural, miraculous way of living was going to help them.
I feel that this kind medical misinformation, like what I saw on Instagram that day, is spreading false hope.
What does this mean?
For now, and for me at least, it doesn’t mean much. Avocatin B still needs to go through animal and human trials, and a lot of drugs that show promise in vitro never make it past those stages. The human body is miraculous and complicated.
This doesn’t mean that I’m dismissing the healthy properties of the humble avocado though. It’s still a food that’s packed with healthy fats, fibre and vitamins.7 So it’s the perfect addition for a healthy diet. And, of course, perfect for posting on Instagram.
Thanks for reading! Sign up to Pandora’s Health to for even more advice, tips and tricks about the latest trends.
- NHS Choices. Acute Myeloid Leukaemia.
- American Cancer Society. How does chemotherpay affect the risk of second cancers?
- U.S. National Library of Medicine. TP53 Gene.
- Wikipedia. Digoxin.
- Lee EA et al. Cancer Research 2015; 75(12).
- The Guardian. ‘None of it’s true’: wellness blogger Belle Gibson admits she never had cancer.
- Medical News Today. Everything you need to know about avocado.
It always cracks me up, personally, when people talk about “curing” cancer. It’s like we’ve lost touch with what “Cure” means and what “Cancer” is caused by / how it works in the first place.
As of right now, you can’t “cure” faulty DNA and cell programming- you can only remove or kill the damaged cells; the closest we’ve come to “curing” cancer in any legitimate sense of the word is a recent technology that’s allowed us to go in, cut out DNA mutations, and manually insert a healthy DNA strain into the cell. But even then, it’s in its infancy and doesn’t work most of the time right now…. And no Food / plant / consumable “all natural anti big pharma” anything is going to do that for you.
Great information. I will still enjoy my guacamole on my tacos.
Thank you for debunking such dangerous health related myths!
Thank you, Sarah, for re-emphasizing and re-educating about “cure” and “cancer”!
As a cancer survivor, there is always the hope for a ‘cure’. The vultures (irresponsible media, business and individuals trying to make a quick buck) prey on people with cancer, who are already vulnerable and trying to ensure survival. Loved this post, keep them coming.
Thank you, Andy! This is something that really bugs me, sadly these kinds of myths can cause a lot of false hope and damage!
Damn. But I mean, they’re still super yummy!
Love this post! My mother in law is a cancer survivor and the sheer amount of ‘nonsense’ around that this cures cancer and that cures cancer is ridiculous. All cancer patients wants to cling on to any hope of a ‘cure’ but in my opinion it has to be medical solutions not just fads that really don’t work. This post was so informative
I completely agree, the hope for a cure is a perfectly human response – the problem is that so many people take advantage of our nature!
I honestly find it quite offensive when people put out false claims like this. There are so many horribly unwell and vulnerable people in the world and to give them false hope is just mean! I have a chronic illness myself and have been through some pretty gruelling treatments for it, two of them started out as chemotherapy treatments but were dismissed as they were found not to work and used for other illnesses. They make you feel like a different person and I can really see why in that state you’d believe or try anything possible to make yourself better. It’s unfair for people to take advantage of it, even if they don’t realise they’re doing it! This was a really interesting post and I’ve definitely learnt some new and valuable information from it, thank you for sharing!